makeovers
    image game
  PPTV image change

Creating the Wave

The Art Director Speaks

Memo From Management

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Prairie Public Art Director Les Skoropat on developing Prairie Public's new image

Q.: What were you asked to do?
I was asked to develop a new logo. It was one of the first directives Kathleen (former Prairie Public President
Kathleen Pavelko) made when she came here.


Q. What was the process you went through to develop the new image?

We put together a committee of community members which included people who worked in the media that had television experience and marketing experience. We told them that we were in the process of coming up with a new logo. What we were after was not so much ideas for a new logo, but how Prairie Public was perceived in the community and how we could present that image to the community. The committee related detailed information as to how the public perceived the staff and the service, how they saw us as an institution, as well as how they saw some of the programs, such as Sesame Street.


Q. What were you hearing?
We heard a lot. We heard everything from the fact that they hated pledge drives, to comments that they respected the services we provided.
Telling us they hated pledge drives wasn't helpful because we already knew about that, but they gave us a list of attributes they wanted us to be: responsible, respectable; a whole list of things we wanted to work with when we thought of the image. We told them it was not possible to put all of these things into a logo, but it gave us some direction and a basis for starting to work with an image.


Q. What happened next?

I went to work on the design. The marketing department discussed the various ideas we came up with in the committee and we distilled them into something I could work with, in visual terms.
I asked Kathleen for an outline of the structure of the corporation. I needed to know how the different divisions fit in the overall corporation. We had Prairie Online. We had Prairie School Television. I asked whether we were looking for separate images for all of these different ventures.


Q. And they decided to go with one logo?

Yes. Knowing that, I designed a symbol that would represent the whole corporation rather than separate identities for each of the divisions or enterprises. It was decided on a corporate level that North Dakota Public Radio would have its own identity.


Q. What thought process did you go through to design the logo?

I leaned heavily on the basics of logo design. A logo design is something that needs to be simple, direct, appropriate. For example, say you're doing a logo for a fence company; you wouldn't want something that looks inappropriate for that particular company. Imagine you designed a logo in the shape of a water droplet; that wouldn't relate to fences. For our company, I wanted to design a logo that would be appropriate for the kind of company we are.
It should be bold, distinctive and unique. It shouldn't look like someone else's logo— that would be confusing.
If it were a very good solution, it would be timeless and contemporary. In terms of its application, it should work well in different sizes and formats.


Q. How did you know a logo should be all of these things?
One learns these things as a design student (and then one forgets these rules). You do some "bad" logos and you think about why it doesn't work, and realize you're breaking some of those basic rules.
I also did some research to see what kinds of logos existed for other public broadcasting stations, how they approached a similar problem. Those that were most helpful were the television and radio networks that weren't identified by call letters or a channel number, but had a name, such as "Oregon Public Broadcasting," because those stations couldn't rely on the channel number or call letters as logo elements. There are some nice logos out there, and some that break the basic rules and don't work as well as they could.


Q. What did those logos tell you about what you wanted to do?

That was more for telling me what not to do. They were already in use. I wouldn't develop one like Oregon Public Broadcasting because people might be confused as to who was who.
I investigated the approaches the logo could take. This refers to how the company is represented. Should it be an "umbrella" logo? Should each division should it have its own logo? I did a number of options like that. It was important that we decided how we wanted to be perceived and then choose a direction.
Then I went about thinking about how to synthesize all of the things we had done with the committee and the information Kathleen had given me on which direction to take.


Q. How do you turn that into a logo?

That's where the skill and experience and art of design comes in. That's kind of like asking a composer, "how do you make music?" He might say, "I learn about tone and scales and then I just make music." You would probably get as many answers as you have composers.
Some of it can't be quantified. You can approach it from a structured setting, and that was a lot of what we did when we were trying to define how the corporation is perceived and how we wanted it to be perceived. When you present a logo you are presenting yourself. When you put it on a letterhead, a van, the side of a building, you are presenting yourself to the public. You're saying, "This is my company. This is my name." In some ways it's a visual shorthand, because you can't convey everything you want to say about your company in one simple mark.
I start sketching, and I had a lot of ideas that I could turn into visual concepts. The image that seemed to work the best with the concepts we talked about was the image of a spiral, which I also combined with portions of circles and ellipses.


Q. What's an ellipse?

An ellipse is an oval.


Q. What were you thinking about when you were drawing?

I tried to keep in mind all of the things that we discussed that had to go into the logo design.


Q. Did you want it to look like a 90's thing?

We wanted it to look contemporary and classic at the same time.