Hype?
Or Help?

We're flooded with hundreds of advertising messages every day. We hear them on the radio, on television. We're also flooded with helpful advice from helpful friends and relatives -- and from quick-buck artists wanting to sell you the latest fountain of youth. How do you sort out the hype from the help?

Anti-Aging Hormones

Consumer Reports on Health notes that it's still unclear how taking so-called anti-aging hormones affects the body -- and that what is known isn't all good. Here's the scoop on six of the most popular anti-aging fads:

DHEA -- short fo dehydroepiandrosterone, DHEA is a precursor to both estrogen and the male hormone testosterone. Clinical trials done in humans have shown little if any benefit and some degree of risk since it can cause huge increases in both estrogen and testosterone levels.

Testosterone -- While the age-relataed decline may contribute to the reduction in bone, muscle, and sexual ability as men age, it is rarely a major cause. There is little evidence that taking testosterone helps relieve those problems. Only men with truly low levels, usually caused by pituitary or testicular disease, should consider testosterone shots or pills.

Melatonin -- While a small, well-timed dose of melatonin migh help some older people sleep better, evidence for the hormone's other supposed anti-aging benefits are far weaker. Melatonin can cause minor side effects such as confusin, drowsiness, and headache. Further, it may worsen sleep apnea, and possibly increase blood pressure and reduce fertility.

Human growth hormone -- Most studies in humans who have moderately reduced growth-hormoone levels have found no significant benefit from supplements. Some research suggestes that supplements may increase the risk of colon cancer, diabetes, heart failure, hypertension, and prostate cancer. A recent French study found that long-time growth-hormone users had a higher death rate than other men.

Antioxidant pills -- Nearly every age related disease, as well as aging itself, as been linked at leat theoretically to oxidation, a common cause of cell damage. Researchers have identified numerous nutrients, including vitamins C and E, beta-carotene, the mineral selenium,a nd a host of other obscure chemicals in plant foods, that fight oxidation and, in theory, help promote healthy aging.

A diet rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and the recommended amount of fish or mean probably provides enough of all of those nutrients -- except vitamin E -- to provide maximum protection with supplements.

Ginkgo -- In a study published in 1997 ginkgo biloba was shown to generate modest improvement in the mental functioning of dementia patients. There is little evidence that the herb can boost memory in healthy people or stem the normal weakening of memory with age.

Ginkgo may inhibit clotting, so people who have bleeding disorders or take blood thinning drugs such as asperin or warfarin should avoid it.

How to Spot Quacks

Your suspicions should be aroused when someone claims that:

  • most Americans are poorly nourished
  • most diseases are due to faulty diet and can be treated with nutritional methods.
  • modern processing methods and storage remove all nutritive value from our food.
  • diet is a major factor in behavior
  • floridation is dangerous
  • soil depletion and the use of pesticides and chemical fertilizers result in food that is less safe and less nourishing
  • you are in danger of being poisoned by ordinary food additives and preservatives
  • the recommended dietary allowances (RDA's) have been set too low
  • they can promise quick, dramatic, miraculous results
  • sugar is a deadly poison
  • they are being persecuted by orthodox medicine and that their work is being suppressed because it's controversial

Or, they recommend or suggest that

  • supplements and health foods are for everyone
  • natural vitamins are better than synthetic ones
  • it is easy to lose weight
  • you should not trust your doctor

The complete list of Twenty-Five Ways to Sport Quacks and Vitamin Pushers is posted on a web site developed by Dr. Stephen Barrett and Dr. Victor Herbert. Visit the Quackwatch web site for details.

How To Sort Out Hype From Help

How do you sort out the hype from the truly helpful information?

  • Ask your doctor. They keep up to date with current research.
  • Read reputable consumer news magazines instead of product brochures.
  • Don't depend on "man on the street" research. Just because people believe something works doesn't mean it does.
  • Make sure that research information is coming from a university, medical center, or other reputable research center.
  • Don't depend on your friends or family for advice. Ask a qualified medical professional.